It isn't exactly an outright victory. The judge ordered Chris Grayling to come up with a report on the state of the franchise within a fortnight, or to face a full-scale judicial review.
It is an important step forward, though not yet a solution. But then one element of their failure to solve the underlying problem is ministers inability to set out honestly what it is. It is so much easier just to blame the unions.
This failure is infuriating in itself. Almost - strange this - more enraging than the failure of the Southern franchise.
This is why I've been thinking about official untruths.
It seems to be a symptom of the endtime of the bundle of economic and political ideas that have dominated for the past four decades, but those in government are forced to lie that much more.
It isn’t necessarily their fault individually. It is just what happens when the bundle of ideas which are supposed to drive the engine of government run dry.
They need to do so to maintain an increasingly stressful façade that everything is fine – that the economy is fuelled by more than debt, that austerity continues to boost the economy, or that a hard Brexit is a pretty neat idea.
It is increasingly difficult to accept in public these small details, which threaten to unravel the big lies they tell each other in government just to get by.
So I thought it might make sense to collect some of the official untruths together. These are in my top ten. What are yours?
Get a free copy of my Brexit thriller on pdf when you sign up for the newsletter of The Real Press.
Subscribe to this blog on email; send me a message with the word blogsubscribe to email@example.com. When you want to stop, you can email me the word unsubscribe.